Wednesday 5 December 2007, by just another SMG/SMP fan :

Yes, because casting directors being in talks with Maggie Grace is surely the same as saying that Sarah has been replaced by her. Wrong! You might want to wait until those "talks" have reached some sort of conclusion. Get definitive casting information before you start proclaiming that a certain actress has been cast.

A better headline for this might have been, "She might be replaced by Maggie Grace!"



Wednesday 5 December 2007, by Captain Jack Sparrow :

well........i’ll just ask sarah myself if she got pulled from the film. i hope she answers the phone.

Thursday 6 December 2007, by Anonymous :

It’s highly unlikely she’s been "yanked". For one, they wouldn’t do it unless they had Grace all lined up beforehand and it wouldn’t appear that they do. For two, Maggie Grace is no upgrade from Sarah. She’s a much smaller name with no background in the genre at all and was Nispel’s #2 choice. You don’t take number 2 if you can have number 1.

My guess would be Gellar walked for some reason, whether it be frustration that the film appears to be going nowhere or because she has something else lined up. There were those recent rumors about her being interested in the new Darren Star project. Alice would only hold that back.



Thursday 6 December 2007, by Captain Jack Sparrow :

she told me that she doesn’t have time AND she wants to explore better options for future rolls...

if sarah michelle gellar were a drug, I’d be in trouble...



Friday 7 December 2007, by Spike :

Sarah is a way bigger star than Maggie Grace. I highly doubt Gellar was pulled from this film. Alot of people haven’t heard of this story before, so adding a big Hollywood name to the project helps reel people in. Otherwise, the movie would be a flop. Maggie Grace is probably in talks for a different character in the movie. Alice will probably still definitly be Gellar.

Monday 4 February 2008, by Deatheater :

No Sarah? What the hell is that all about.... No Sarah, no money from me!

These comments are an anwser to this article : Sarah Michelle Gellar - "Alice" Movie - She’s replaced by Maggie Grace !

« Previous comment to : "Buffy" Tv Series - Wesley - Greatest Fight Scenes - Watch The Video
     Next comment to : Buffy Cast caricature in GMan 2008 Free Calendar »