Homepage > Joss Whedon Off Topic > Doctor Who arrives in modern times. And it works. (gellar mention)
« Previous : Joss Whedon - Does Wonder Woman hail from Orange County ?
     Next : Michelle Branch - One Tree Hill Tour March 2005 - Medium quality Photos »

From Telegraph.co.uk

Doctor Who arrives in modern times. And it works. (gellar mention)

By Stephen Pile

Saturday 26 March 2005, by Webmaster

After a long absence Doctor Who lands at 7pm on BBC1 on Saturday, smack, bang, up-to-date. It works. Thumbs up. Let them live.

It is like watching a completely new programme but with enough references to the great tradition to make it authentic. It has the Tardis, the monsters, the female companion responsible for the sexual awakening of boy viewers everywhere, the sonic screwdriver and that crucial balance between scariness and comedy. But no scarves.

Gone are the flamboyance and the air of theatricality. The theme tune is more edgily orchestrated, like the whole show.

Christopher Eccleston’s doctor, with his black leather jacket and northern accent, is modern, urban and of today, manically driven by his desire to save the world.

His new assistant, Rose (Billie Piper), lives on a housing estate. She has a black boyfriend and a mum in tracksuit bottoms who is only interested in getting compensation for her daughter’s distress during an attack of the Autons.

Rose did not know what a blue police box was, never mind a Tardis.

Watching a preview tape, we adults thought it was state-of-the-art ("Wow, we never had faces morphing like that"), whereas the children, raised on The Matrix and Buffy the Vampire Slayer, found it charmingly low-tech, particularly when Dr Who was attacked by the disembodied arm of a possessed shop dummy.

"There’s hardly any CGI," they observed. (Computer-generated imagery. Catch up.)

Eccleston is such an electrifying actor that he conveys the doctor’s alien status (he is 900 years old with two hearts) by the means of wide-eyed, slightly unhinged over-enthusiasm.

He has real chemistry with Piper’s Rose, who is the most interesting development of all. Like the Roman centurion’s costume, Doctor Who constantly evolved during its lifetime. The female companion, for example, changed from a screaming, helpless girl only good for rescuing into a feisty, independent young thing, like Leela in her leather leotard or street-wise Ace. Rose is post-feminist. Soft, feminine, caring and unashamedly attractive but she still saves her pathetic boyfriend, and even Doctor Who, with a moment of no-fuss girl power. Russell T Davies’s script is vastly better than anything before it and the scariness, this week at least, seems more everyday.

Under the London Eye, a seething, malevolent porridge of alien consciousness is bringing plastic everywhere to life aimed at wiping out humanity. It includes dolls, shop mannequins and, as Rose says, "breast implants".

Will it be popular? This is not for an adult to say. My teenage son twice purred "This is really cool," which augurs well. But he worried that his friends would not watch it. "It’s sad watching programmes your parents liked." Do these children have no sense of tradition?