Joss Whedon

News Flash: People magazine doesn’t cater to gay men. Every year they decree the "Sexiest Man Alive," and more often not, we’re left scratching our heads over the selections. So following in the footsteps of our sister site AfterEllen.com (which created their own Hot 100 list last month in response to Maxim’s annual list), we at AfterElton.com took it upon ourselves to see what would happen if we asked gay and bisexual men — and gay and bisexual men only — to vote for their favorite fellas. Thousands of votes later, we have the results.

1. Jake Gyllenhaal
2. Chris Evans
3. Daniel Craig
4. Gale Harold
5. Taye Diggs
6. Ryan Reynolds
7. Hugh Jackman
8. T.R. Knight
9. Ryan Philippe
10. John Barrowman

26. Wentworth Miller (Gage Petronzi in Buffy’s "Go Fish" episode)

99. Seth Green