Homepage > Joss Whedon’s Tv Series > Angel > Reviews > When Is A Door Not A Door? - Angel S5 Review
« Previous : Angel 5x18-19-20 Behind The Scene - Sci Fi Scan
     Next : James Marsters : UK’s Favorite To Play Romeo »



When Is A Door Not A Door? - Angel S5 Review

Daniel Erenberg

Thursday 22 April 2004, by cally


When Is A Door Not A Door?

by Daniel Erenberg

Lately, I’ve been getting crucified on various comment boards for an article I didn’t even write. A month or so ago, Ron, the big man of the site and long-time regular Buffy and Angel reviewer, wrote an article called “We’ll Always Have Sunnydale” that sent a chill through my spine by listing all the ways that Ron hated season five of Angel, a season that I’ve been enjoying immensely (though it has had more than its share of bumps in the road). It surprised me. I thought that generally most people dug the latest season. I was write, I soon found out, when a bunch of people that thought I had written that article, responded to my last one “To Shanshu On TV” by asking why I would want to write about Angel if I hate it so much. But I don’t. So I offer my capsule reviews of every episode of season five. Here you go.

Angel 5.1: “Conviction”, written and directed by Joss Whedon.

This wasn’t one of Joss’s better efforts. I mean, don’t get me wrong. Nothing the man writes is without merit (have you read the comic “Tales Of The Vampire” lately?), but this just wasn’t a classic. It did a nice job of setting up the season and introducing a few new characters, but so did Tim Minear’s “Home” at the end of last season. The one thing it did wrong was not letting every character have something interesting to do. It was very much The Angel Show, which is what the show was initially, but it’s evolved into an ensemble drama, and this has to be taken into account.

Angel 5.2: “Just Rewards”, written by David Fury and Ben Edlund, and directed by James A. Contner.

This was the first major Spike-driven episode on Angel since episode three of season one (“In The Dark”). At this point, a good rapport was developed between Angel and Spike, but Spike was still comic relief and the non-corporeal angle wasn’t worked well. The villain in the episode was smartly written and had a good motive, but this one was strictly stand-alone.

Angel 5.3: “Unleashed”, written by Sarah Fain and Elizabeth Craft, and directed by Marita Grabiak.

Another stand-alone, but this one slightly better than the last. However, in a weird move, this season has chosen to ignore a lot of Buffy continuity and there is no Oz reference to be had in this Werewolf-Centric episode. It does introduce the character of Nina who, while having virtually nothing in the way of actual character, is at least pretty and does add a much-needed female voice to the show that is sorely lacking being that Fred is the only regular at this point.

Angel 5.4: “Hell Bound”, written and directed by Stephen S. DeKnight.

This one was typical DeKnight darkness and nowhere near as successful as his brand of writing was in season four (in instant classics like “Deep Down” and “Apocalypse, Nowish”). This is yet another stand-alone and not as good as the last one. Spike is the star of the show here.

Angel 5.5: “Life Of The Party”, written by Ben Edlund, and directed by Bill L. Norton.

Edlund shines in this one. I’ve been a big fan of his writing in the past (in The Tick and last year’s great Firefly episode “Jaynestown”), but last year’s Angel offering “Sacrifice” was the one blunder of the season. However, “Life Of The Party” is a step up giving Lorne a rare center stage, and his first since episode three of season four (“The House Always Wins”). It’s funny, it’s interesting, and it’s probably the best since “Conviction”. Also, Eve gets to be a far more interesting character right here.

Angel 5.6: “The Cautionary Tale Of Numero Cinco”, written and directed by Jeffrey Bell.

The last boring stand-alone of season five and the last stop before the major plotlines ramp up. This reintroduces the idea of the Shanshu prophecy. Some mildly diverting stuff happens and, before long, we’re right back where we started. Might hold up over time though.

Angel 5.7: “Lineage”, written by Drew Goddard and directed by Jefferson Kibbee.

Well, okay! This is one of my favorite episodes of the season. Drew Goddard’s first Angel, and he knocked it out of the park. A beautiful characterization of Wesley. It’s good to see him take center stage. He’s probably my favorite character on the show, and he hadn’t been given anything to do really since last season. There’s good stuff with Knox in this episode, good stuff with Eve in this episode, and Roger Wyndham-Price is exactly how I imagined him. The plot twist at the end could have come off ridiculous, but somehow didn’t.

Angel 5.8: “Destiny”, written by David Fury and Stephen S. DeKnight, and directed by Skip Schoolnik.

Sure, the appearances by Drusilla seem arbitrary and needless. Sure, the idea of a Cup Of Perpetual Sorrow seems stupid and embarrassing. Sure, Spike’s recorporealization seems sudden and jarring. But, all that aside, it works. Spike and Angel work truly great together for the first time since “Just Rewards”. Harmony’s funny, Eve is enigmatic, and Lindsey returns (!) in a masterstroke.

Angel 5.9: “Harm’s Way”, written by Elizabeth Craft and Sarah Fain, and directed by Vern Gillum.

For the first time since season two’s “Disharmony”, Harmony Kendall takes center stage and blows the house down with her particular brand of humor. It’s light, it’s funny, it works. This is one stand-alone I didn’t mind in the slightest.

Angel 5.10: “Soul Purpose”, written by Brent Fletcher, and directed by David Boreanaz.

Boreanaz did a really good job directing this one actually. The visuals are interesting and rich. The mystery draws you in. The creatures are a better version of the ones in Buffy’s “Bad Eggs”. The dream sequences are in turn bizarre, funny, sad, dark, interesting, terrible, or great. This one works, particularly Spike’s newfound work relationship with Lindsey acting as Doyle.

Angel 5.11: “Damage”, written by Stephen S. DeKnight and Drew Goddard, and directed by Jefferson Kibbee.

Andrew is as good here as he was in season seven last year. He probably gave his best performance here since Buffy’s “Storyteller”. We see the fall-out from “Chosen”, we see the Scooby Gang’s new opinion on Angel, we see some big funny, Spike is great, the information on the Scoobys is PERFECTION. And Crazy Slayer Girl kept my interest too. The only downside was the real lack of tension when Spike’s hands got cut off. That should have been a bigger moment.

Angel 5.12: “You’re Welcome”, written and directed by David Fury.

Up to February 4, when this episode aired, it was the crown jewel of the season. Cordelia came back and was fantastic, Lindsey returned and was equally brilliant, the final fight was brutal and great. Seeing Glen Quinn in video from season one’s “Hero” was heartbreaking, but not as heartbreaking as the last scene of the show, a scene that made me cry and effected me for a long time after the credits rolled. Also, David Fury proves himself an excellent director. He’s done a fine job.

Angel 5.13: “Why We Fight”, written by Stephen S. DeKnight and Drew Goddard, and directed by Terrence O’Hara.

This episode didn’t need to exist. “Smile Time” should have come immediately after “You’re Welcome”. It’s a blemish on the fine records of Mr. Goddard and Mr. DeKnight. The supporting characters are stupid, the flashbacks don’t work, and, for a character so unique to the Buffyverse as Lawson (as the only human ever turned by a vamp with a soul), he certainly isn’t paid much mind. There is some good tension in Act 4, but it doesn’t matter.

Angel 5.14: “Smile Time”, written by Ben Edlund from a story by Joss Whedon and Ben Edlund, and directed by Ben Edlund.

Another fine offering from Edlund. This contains one of the funniest scenes in Angel history when Puppet Angel fights Spike. Spike’s, “Well you’re a wee little puppet man” is laughing-fit-inducing. Also, it was an easy joke, but Puppet Angel vamping out was hilarious. Nina comes back in this one and is far more interesting than she was in “Unleashed”. Harmony and Knox also continue to work well as characters. Only downside is the initiation of the Wesley/Fred relationship which, while great, seems a bit rushed.

Angel 5.15: “A Hole In The World”, written and directed by Joss Whedon.

Now THIS is a Joss Whedon episode; full of revelations (Knox is EVIL), great characters new (Drogyn) and old (Pretty much the entire cast), beautiful dialogue (Spike’s monologue about the titular hole, and the various arguments about Astronauts and Cavemen), great fight scenes (Spike and Angel-“you remembered”), wonderful continuity references (Eve singing Lindsey’s song from season two’s “Dead End”), and a pulse-pounding cliffhanger (Fred dies and becomes Illyria).

Angel 5.16: “Shells”, written and directed by Stephen S. DeKnight.

I don’t know how others feel about this one, but it really hit home for me. I’m not going to give you a list of great moments, because I feel it’s the best episode of the season so far. I loved it so much. Everything was great, especially the book-ending conversations between Wesley and Illyria. Not to mention, the death of Knox, the stabbing of Gunn, and just Dark Wesley in general.

Angel 5.17: “Underneath”, written by Sarah Fain and Elizabeth Craft, and directed by Skip Schoolnik.

Fain and Craft did their best writing here since last year’s “Soulless”. The Illyria/Wesley stuff is emotionally draining and brilliantly written. The stuff with Harmony (a new regular), Lorne, and Eve running from the new character Hamilton is fantastic and it really moves. (And I love Firefly’s Adam Baldwin. Sing it with me if you know the words-“A Man naaaamed Jayne.”) Finally Lindsey returns and is just as exciting as he was back at the front end of the year. It can only get better from here.

Daniel Erenberg lives in a gothic-looking house in a suburb of Long Island shrouded by trees and darkness. His backyard is so overrun with shrubbery that he can’t plant flowers in the soil. He’s penned articles for numerous magazines (and a couple of websites for free). Currently, he’s writing his first novel, entitled People That I’ve Long Since Forgotten. He’s also written two plays, Little Room and Dystopia and a screenplay called Youth Or Consequence. He lives a fairly happy life alone except for the mind-numbing loneliness he feels on occasion. If you’re a beautiful woman that’s fallen in love with Daniel, or you just want to talk Buffy with him, you can contact Daniel at daniel@slayage.com.

3 Forum messages

  • > When Is A Door Not A Door? - Angel S5 Review

    23 April 2004 01:23, by clodia
    Not to quibble, but didn’t Spike turn a number of people during season 7 of Buffy, that is to say, after he gained a soul? I know that he was under the control of the First at that point, but would those whom he turned have felt the same as Lawson?
  • > When Is A Door Not A Door? - Angel S5 Review

    23 April 2004 21:41, by John from NC

    Spike didn’t turn anyone DA, he simply killed them.

    To Daniel: You disliked some good episodes, "Conviction", "Hell Bound", and "The Cautionary Tale Of Numero Cinco".

    Now I admit "Why We Fight" wasn’t very good, but it’d showed us more of what Angel was like before Buffy and had a bit of backstory of The Initiative. Also why would Lawson be paid much attention, he just wanted to die. It’s not like he was truly evil, he had no purpose and and no reason to go on. It was a great show.

  • > When Is A Door Not A Door? - Angel S5 Review

    24 April 2004 19:49, by Wolverine68

    Why didn’t Tim Minear give each character something to do? Hmm, did you ever hear of the words "alloted time?" Perhaps he did thimnk aobut htat, but it had to be taken out for time? We don’t know. I would have liked to see what lorne was doing, but him talking to movie stars cruscal to the plot, and on TV you have limits of what you can do.

    Ont ot season 5.

    Conviction-Good but basic. Mp>

    Just Rewards-um, why wasn’t this Convicvtion part 2, or written be Joss?

    Unleashed-OK, still basic plots here, big deal, it’;s the begining of the season. (Oh, and Fred is not the only female charactr, they added in Harmoney.)

    Hellbound-A really good episode, where they dared to get egdy. Not the best work, but still the most enjoyable episode in a long time.

    Life Of The Party-at this point the best episode of season 5 to me, but disapointed me with a lagging fight scene against evil Lorne, other then that has me laughing & loving it all night.

    The Cautionary Tale Of Numero Cinco-Not boring, though it did seem stupid from the comercial (solely). I rather enjoyed this one, while the plot was not Angel’s best, it provided some nice fight scenes, that we have not scene for long while.

    Lineage-This is the 1st step in the plot thickening, showing that this will definatly be an aboce average season. The disappointment is we never see these androids again on the show, or find out anything more (which is an even all to often in the Angel world).

    Destiny-The start of the subtile season arch, and the best episode (so far). The high point is Angel & Spike fighting out their difference, for over an act of the show. The low point is no Darla, we know from season 2 that Darla prefers Angel to the master, and does not come calling to his becons.

    Harm’s Way-The low point (ie worst episode) of the season, and yet still enjoyable. At this point Harmoney was not a cast character and this was not needed for her or wanted.

    Soul Purpose-I feel this episosde should have came after Destiny, but oh well. This steals the title of best episode (so far). DB was a great director. I am glad they didn’t give him an all to easy job to direct like Harm’s Way (but he should have been directing sooner then this).

    Damage-Another really good episode filled with good fight scenes as well. The end did disapoint me, as Angel could have had his army take down the slayers.

    You’re Welcome-The best episode of the season (& I am not saying so far now), and hte only episode of Angel to bring a tear to my eye. It was so well written, so realistic, so tragic, & such a great fight scene on top of that. (Heck, this might be the best episode ever.)

    Why We Fight-I liked it, but did not like falling back to mediocre episodes. Basically, it should have came before Destiny. (It falls as a mediocre or elt down to everyone, because all the other flashback eps were so so much better.)

    Smile Time-A work of genious & comes close to being hte best episode. Not since Hercules was turned to a pig have I laguhed so much. Even as a puppet Amgel gave us 2 great fight scenes. (I do not think Wes & Fred were rushed together, they have waited years for this, duh!)

    A Hole In The World-Good plot, not Whedon’s finest ever, but his best effort for the Angel series. I was glad to see him write more then one episode this year. (It’s been 3 years since he wrote more then one episode of Angel.)

    Shells-I liked it, but only in an over all sense. I was (as most people I know) let down by the end. There was no shocking end to pull us in, just a video/flash back attempting to get us sad.

    Underneath-One of the best episodes of the season, and an appearence by a cool monter into S&M. Great plot, and really good fight scene(s) at the top of act 3. The best work of Fain & Craft, I stand convinced that they are wirth of writting for Angel. (Souless may have been a good episode for them, but Steven S. DeKnight co-wrote it with them.)

    Origin (& beyond)- a great closure to the Connor plot line, as I am sure the rest will be. The writters as great, and never let me down (ok once with that Jasmin plot, but I trust them now that).

    This season was the best & most edgy since season 2. I could even feel this from the 1st few episode, and said "wow, I have not enjotyed Angel this much in years." Season 5 makes me glad I didn’t stop watching as Cordy slept with Connor & lame demons like Jasmin came on the show.