21 May 2005 05:02, by Anonymous
Some points made are irrelevant, such as the race issue. The first point is somewhat irrelevant to the comparison also. Charmed is a show about witchcraft, of course the witchcraft must be more consistent. Buffy is not a show about witches (not primarily anyway).
Lots of the points made about the good always be good/stay true to themselves, always clear who the bad guy is, and such, only say Charmed is a more cliched and unoriginal show, I don’t see how those make it a better (...)